Malta’s Citizenship Ruling Enters Spain’s Debate over the ‘Grandchildren Law’

Malta’s citizenship controversy has resurfaced in the Spanish press, where the European Court’s ruling against its investor citizenship programme is being invoked in a challenge to Spain’s so-called “grandchildren law”.
The Spanish news outlet The Objective reports that Juan Gallego has petitioned the European Parliament over the compatibility of Spain’s nationality provisions with European Union law. His argument draws on the judgment delivered against Malta on 29 April 2025. According to the newspaper, his petition has been admitted for consideration and opened for supporting signatures. This is a reported procedural development, rather than a ruling that Spain has breached EU law.
For Maltese readers, the interest lies in how a judgment concerning Malta is now being used to question citizenship policies elsewhere in Europe. However, the comparison requires care: the Maltese case concerned citizenship granted through a transactional investment scheme, while the Spanish provisions concern nationality through family descent and historical redress.
Spain’s “grandchildren law” is the popular name associated with nationality provisions in the Democratic Memory Law of 2022. These created routes to Spanish nationality for specified categories of descendants of Spaniards, including families affected by exile, children of Spanish women who lost their nationality through marriage to foreigners before the 1978 Constitution, and certain adult children of people whose Spanish nationality had been recognised under memory legislation.
Gallego’s petition, as described by The Objective, questions whether the Spanish arrangements grant EU citizenship without adequate safeguards concerning an effective connection to Spain and the circumstances of exile. He seeks scrutiny by the European institutions and consideration of possible infringement proceedings. These remain the petitioner’s allegations and requests.
The Maltese judgment provides a significant reference point, but its scope must be understood accurately. In Commission v Malta, Case C-181/23, the Court of Justice found that Malta’s institutionalised scheme exchanged naturalisation for predetermined payments or investments, thereby commercialising national and EU citizenship. It held that Malta had breached Article 20 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union and the duty of sincere cooperation under Article 4(3) of the Treaty on European Union. The judgment did not establish a general prohibition on granting citizenship to large numbers of people.
The Spanish report also refers to the Micheletti judgment of 7 July 1992. That case affirmed that member states determine the conditions for acquiring and losing nationality, while respecting European law. Yet its context is equally relevant: the Court also prevented Spain from denying the benefits of Italian nationality to a person who held both Italian and Argentine citizenship. It therefore cannot simply be read as a precedent for restricting citizenship acquired through descent.
The broader significance for Malta is that its citizenship case has become a reference point in a dispute extending beyond investment programmes. Critics of Spain’s legislation are seeking to apply its reasoning to a different route to nationality.
Whether that argument succeeds will depend on the legal merits of the Spanish arrangements. For now, what the Spanish coverage demonstrates is the continuing influence of the Malta judgment—and the need to distinguish between invoking a precedent and establishing that it applies.
